Tough for Meta to get interim relief against CCI order: Experts

American tech giant Meta may find it tough to get interim relief against the Competition Commission of India’s (CCI’s) Rs 213-crore penalty on it for its alleged abuse of the dominant position of its messaging app WhatsApp, according to competition law experts.

“It would not be easy for the appeal court to disagree with the CCI’s view on Meta coercing Whatsapp users to consent to the 2021 privacy policy given it had opt-out provisions for users in other countries. India would be reluctant to send a message that it is willing to allow user data to be commercially exploited without free and informed consent,” said Vivek Agarwal, partner at DMD Advocates.

Also ReadUK-India Free Trade Agreement to relaunch in early 2025: What’s at stake?

Given the magnitude of remedies mentioned by CCI, Meta’s immediate focus would be to secure some interim protection from the appeal court. For instance, the CCI order said that WhatsApp will not share user data collected on its platform with other Meta companies or Meta company products for advertising purposes for a period of 5 years from the date of receipt of the order.

“Meta is likely to push for some immediate relief on the ground that the remedy of imposing a complete embargo on WhatsApp to share its user data with other Meta companies is disproportionate. Without securing some interim protection, Meta would be obliged to comply with the CCI order within three months,” said Agarwal.

Also ReadMeeting the needs of global Indian diaspora: International festive deliveries for cross-border celebration

Experts said that instead of putting embargo on Meta to stop sharing data with other company platforms, CCI could have also suggested Meta to give options to its users to pay for its services or “opt-in” for data sharing mechanism. “When user data is used for purpose other than advertising, CCI should have given option to WhatsApp to either require the users who don’t agree to sharing of data to pay for the services or refrain from using its services. Since data is the price user pays for the services of WhatsApp, it would have been appropriate to give the company this option rather than allowing it to terminate service to such users altogether,” said former member of the commission Augustine Peter.

 » Read More

Related Articles

Three-year car insurance: Are you still buying motor insurance annually?

By Paras Pasricha Every year, like clockwork, car owners face the same familiar reminder of renewing their car insurance. Between busy schedules and endless to-do lists, it’s easy to push it to the last minute or even let it slip through the cracks. But skipping renewal isn’t just a minor inconvenience, it could leave you

Nifty on the edge of a precipice

By V K Sharma The Nifty closed at 22,795.90 on Friday, its lowest closing level since reaching an all-time high of 26,277.35 on September 27. The Nifty has gone below the 22,800 mark four times in intra-day terms but has always managed to bounce back above it on a closing basis. This puts the Nifty

Experts seek clarity on new I-T rules for NPOs

While the Income Tax Bill, 2025 has consolidated the tax laws governing non-profit organisations (NPOs), tax experts have sought more clarity on the criteria for these entities to qualify for tax concessions. The new Bill seeks to explain ‘permissible commercial activities’ for registered NPOs – a feature which was absent in the extant I-T Act

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Stay Connected

0FansLike
0FollowersFollow
0SubscribersSubscribe
- Advertisement -

Latest Articles

Three-year car insurance: Are you still buying motor insurance annually?

By Paras Pasricha Every year, like clockwork, car owners face the same familiar reminder of renewing their car insurance. Between busy schedules and endless to-do lists, it’s easy to push it to the last minute or even let it slip through the cracks. But skipping renewal isn’t just a minor inconvenience, it could leave you

Nifty on the edge of a precipice

By V K Sharma The Nifty closed at 22,795.90 on Friday, its lowest closing level since reaching an all-time high of 26,277.35 on September 27. The Nifty has gone below the 22,800 mark four times in intra-day terms but has always managed to bounce back above it on a closing basis. This puts the Nifty

Experts seek clarity on new I-T rules for NPOs

While the Income Tax Bill, 2025 has consolidated the tax laws governing non-profit organisations (NPOs), tax experts have sought more clarity on the criteria for these entities to qualify for tax concessions. The new Bill seeks to explain ‘permissible commercial activities’ for registered NPOs – a feature which was absent in the extant I-T Act

‘We expect prices to rise by 8-12% in our projects’

Bengaluru based property developer Brigade Enterprises reported a more than threefold jump in its Q3 consolidated net profit to Rs 236.24 crore and its sales bookings rose 63% to Rs 2,492 crore in the December quarter. Pavitra Shankar, managing director, Brigade Enterprises, talks to Raghavendra Kamath about the company’s plans and outlook for the real

Delhivery expands road trains for auto, FMCG

Third-party logistics provider Delhivery is betting big on road trains — tractor units towing multiple trailers — to transform transportation for high-volume sectors like automobiles and fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG). The company believes this innovation will significantly reduce costs and enhance efficiency. Arun Bagavathi, network design head at Delhivery, told FE that logistics is a